Oversight and accountability of the intelligence community. While oversight of intelligence agencies can take a number of forms, legislative oversight is often seen as particularly important as it can help ensure agencies. Of particular relevance with this act is the first of its eight sections that is aptlyy titles reform of the intelligence community. Permanent, continuing, daytoday congressional oversight of the us intelligence community ic marked its 20th anniversary in may 1996. Oversight of the united states national security agencies united states intelligence community oversight duties are shared by both the executive and legislative branches of the government. United states intelligence community oversight wikipedia. Does congressional oversight enable the ic to be more effective, better funded, and better organized, or does it. Kibbe states three distinct reasons why congressional oversight of the intelligence community is important.
Now with his sixth edition of this classic work, he reaches new heights of excellence in research and presentation. Strengthening congressional oversight of the intelligence community. Representative adam schiff condemned donald trumps decision to fire the inspector general of the intelligence community michael atkinson, warning that the president was gutting the independence. Congressional oversight of the intelligence community belfer. But they should also ask whether they should engage in particular intelligence activities even if they can as a matter of law.
When these interests are involved there should be more congressional oversight, not less. What is left of the us intelligence community is a few civilian analysts like andrew mccarthy. Dec 10, 20 intelligence oversight and accountability. George mason university hosts a discussion on congress oversight role of the intelligence community. A thesis submitted to the faculty of the school of continuing studies and of the graduate school of arts and sciences in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of master of arts in liberal studies by victor h harris, b. Office of intelligence and analysis intelligence oversight. What is the process of ensuring that agencies within the intelligence community collect, retain and disseminate information concerning us person only in accordance with federal law, executive orders, dod directives, regulations and policies. The senates torture report shows how hamstrung congressional oversight of the intelligence community really is. The first reason is because of the natural secrecy of intelligence and exclusion of the public and media playing a supporting role in aiding congress in monitoring the intelligence community s activities kibbe 2010. Concurrently, a bipartisan quartet of organizations made indepth. Today 33 organizations called on the house of representatives to strengthen its oversight of the intelligence community. Jan 23, 2017 office of intelligence and analysis intelligence oversight program and guidelines. Subcommittees on the central intelligence agency cia of the congressional armed services. Committee members routinely become cheerleaders or ostriches rather than skeptics and guardians.
Frank john smist foreseeing conflict between the legislative and executive branches over the proper functions of government, the founders of the united states built. The secret history of the mossad by gordon thomas, legacy of ashes. Intelligence, united states congressional oversight of judson knight although the united states congress served as facilitator to the establishment of the u. You can find more info on the laws and rules that apply to intelligence here. Covert action and clandestine activities of the intelligence community. Congressional oversight of intelligence is a joke cato. The united states senate select committee on intelligence sometimes referred to as the intelligence committee or ssci is dedicated to overseeing the united states intelligence community the agencies and bureaus of the federal government of the united states who provide information and analysis for leaders of the executive and legislative branches. The intelligence community ic is again being encouraged to take.
The director of national intelligence submits this summary consistent with direction in section 5061 of the national security act of 1947 50 u. Congress wins expanded oversight of intelligence community. Many of the mistakes made in the last 20 years were avoidable, and, if oversight of the ic does not change, more will occur. The greatest challenge facing congressional oversight is lack of incentives and time to oversee the management of intelligence affairs. Since the mid1970s, congress s oversight of the intelligence community ic has been a fundamental component of ensuring that the ic s seventeen diverse elements are held accountable for the effectiveness of their programs supporting united states national security. Aug 23, 20 intelligence oversight committees are no different.
Intelligence community agencies already spend substantial resources on ensuring that programs are both lawfully designed and compliant with law in practice. Today, the house permanent select committee on intelligence. Current structure and alternatives congressional research service summary interest in congressional oversight of intelligence has risen again in recent congresses, in part because of disputes over reporting to congress by intelligence community ic components on. Since the mid1970s, congresss oversight of the intelligence community ic has been a. This confusion is understandable, because while i think oversight is an apt term in many ways, it does not cast much light on the actual work of the committee and its staff. Proponents of congressional intelligence oversight argued that openness and accountability were the cornerstone of a legitimate foreign policy, and it was believed that congress, due to its diversity of opinion, possessed greater wisdom than the executive branch. That includes his actions in handling the ukraine whistleblower complaint, which the then acting director of national intelligence stated in congressional testimony was done by the book and. Generally oversight bodies look at the following general issues.
Congressional oversight of intelligence is broken, which. However, formatting rules can vary widely between applications and fields of interest or study. Improving congresss oversight of the intelligence community. This sixth edition now features a new twocolour interior design and lowenthals reliable and thorough updating. United states intelligence community oversight wikimili. Current structure and alternatives summary interest in congressional oversight of intelligence has risen again in the 110th congress, in part because of the house democratic majoritys pledge to enact the remaining recommendations from the u. Congressional oversight of the intelligence community kindle edition by william shields. Sep, 2016 today 33 organizations called on the house of representatives to strengthen its oversight of the intelligence community. The first chapter is devoted to the historical aspect of forming an intelligence capability for the united states. George mason university hosted a discussion on congress oversight role of the intelligence community. The president informed congress of the move in a fridayevening letter to the house and. Why the intelligence community needs gao oversight.
A mix of policy oversight and compliance oversight. The united states intelligence community ic is a group of separate united states government. Pogo asks the house to strengthen congressional oversight. Oversight, in this case, is the supervision of intelligence agencies, and making them accountable for their actions. Although the united states congress served as facilitator to the establishment of the u. Intelligence oversight priorities for the 116th congress.
For most of my compatriots, secret intelligence evokes thoughts of bletchley park and james bond rather than the stasi or extraordinary rendition. Intelligence oversight specialist jobs, employment. As time went on, there evolved a need to have effective mechanisms to oversee this community. The united states intelligence community ic is a group of 14 agencies and organizations responsible for conducting intelligence activities necessary to the national security of the united states and the success of its foreign relations. Trump fires intelligence community watchdog who defied him. Intelligence community leadership and oversight, advisory. Intelligence oversight committees are being stocked with. Puyvelde 20, 141 observes that senior policymakers and intelligence officers have at crucial times, demonstrated a reluctance to submit intelligence agencies to external oversight. This commission, chaired by former defense sectretary les aspin and, after his death, by another former defense.
Congressional oversight of the intelligence community is broken the response to the russia investigation and gina haspels cia nomination reveals a watchdog complicit in protecting the president. The incident command system ics is a standardized approach to the command, control, and coordination of emergency response providing a common hierarchy within which responders from multiple agencies can be effective. This 4day class is conducted entirely on capitol hill. Congressional oversight and the crippling of the cia. May 16, 2018 over the years, congressional oversight of the intelligence community has wrestled with the balance between support and oversight, the extent of member and staff access to intelligence information, the challenge of transparency in a highly classified enterprise, and how to approach appropriating intelligence funding. America was attacked and it needed every tool available to defend itself from future assault. Trump is already trying to get around cares act oversight. According to intelligence and congressional officials, congressional oversight of the central intelligence agency and the national security agency is after a bumpy beginning. Nsa reports to the presidents intelligence oversight board iob. Atkinson, who had served as the intelligence community inspector general since may 2018, was the first to alert congress last year of the whistleblower complaint. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading congressional oversight of the intelligence community. Oct 17, 2011 clearancejobs is your best resource for news and information on securitycleared jobs and professionals. A final historical perspective of value in making judgments about the future shape of intelligence community oversight is the manner in which congress seeks to put out fires. She argues that many of the biggest oversight problems lie with congress the institution, not the parties or personalitiesshowing how congress has collectively and persistently tied its own hands in.
Current structure and alternatives congressional research service 4. Trump fires intelligence community watchdog who defied him on whistleblower complaint. With recent developments in mind, he highlights new challenges facing the intelligence community, including the effects of the snowden leaks in terms of collection and congressional oversight, as well as discussing nsa programs, uavs, and the impact of social media. Congressional oversight of intelligence sufficient. Congress monitors and regulates intelligence programs and authorizes and appropriates funds.
Background on congressional intelligence oversight. Former members of the congressional intelligence committees participate in a panel moderated by. United states senate select committee on intelligence. Congress finds that section 502 of the national security act of 1947 50 u. This report provides an overview of the united states intelligence communitys ic. When questions were raised about the activities of the intelligence community in the 1970s, congress reacted by forming two special committees, colloquially known as the pike and church committees. United states intelligence community news newspapers books scholar jstor july 2018. Participants talked about a comprehensive study of congressional oversight of the u.
Congressional research service reports and was provided by unt libraries government documents department to unt digital library, a digital repository hosted by the unt libraries. Learn more with our article, intelligence community reading list for the cleared job seeker. What does effective intelligence oversight look like. Since the mid1970s, congress s oversight of the intelligence community ic has been a fundamental component of ensuring that the ics seventeen diverse elements are held accountable for the effectiveness of. The firing of the intelligence community inspector general, michael atkinson, is concerning. Congressional oversight of policy directives and guidance. The senate select committee on intelligence ssci and house permanent select committee on intelligence hspci were created in 1976 and 1977, respectively. Sep 08, 2017 intelligence oversight committees are being stocked with former intelligence agency employees. The release includes quarterly reports submitted from the fourth quarter of 2001 to the second quarter of 20. In making this choice though, congress opened the door to a new era of ic programs that pushed the line of legality and morality. The creation of the intelligence community was derived from the national security act of 1947 which sought a need to have an organized community specifically geared towards the collection of intelligence to prevent strategic surprise.
I am having a hard time conceiving of a legitimate reason why the rest of the congressional intelligence committees should be kept in the dark about this program. Governing security in the twentyfirst century goldman, zachary k. Former members of the congressional intelligence committees, including jane harman, mike rogers, saxby chambliss and bill nelson, participated in a panel. Senate select committee on intelligence released the executive summary of its longer report into the central intelligence agencys cia use of enhanced interrogation methods after 911. Framework for congressional oversight in brief updated august 9, 2019 open pdf 979 kb from the document. Apply to intelligence specialist, security specialist, intelligence analyst and more. Intelligence, united states congressional oversight of.
These actions are of a piece with this administrations attitude toward congressional oversight more. Since the mid1970s, congress s oversight of the intelligence community ic has been a fundamental component of ensuring that the ics seventeen diverse elements are held accountable for the effectiveness of their programs supporting united states national security. Apr 14, 2018 the senate select committee on intelligence and house permanent select committee on intelligence need to be aware of how the money is being spent and what programs are occurring. Congressional oversight of the intelligence community is broken the response to the russia investigation and gina haspels cia nomination reveals a. The integrity of intelligence oversight is at risk the. Congressional oversight of the intelligence community is. Intelligence oversight and surveillance reform act 20. It comes on the heels of other disturbing changes that. Then, in the 1970s, as distrust of the executive branch grew in the wake of the.
Concurrently, a bipartisan quartet of organizations made indepth recommendations on how the house should update its intelligence oversight rules. Adam schiff denounces trumps firing of inspector general. Improving congress s oversight of the intelligence community by phillip lohaus, daniel schuman and mandy smithberger 012417 05. United states intelligence community oversight duties are shared by both the executive and legislative branches of the government. Our mission is to engage in policy research and outreach to promote free markets and limited, effective. Amy zegart examines the weaknesses of us intelligence oversight and why those deficiencies have persisted, despite the unprecedented importance of intelligence in todays environment. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. I have entitled my notes this morning oversight or overlook. This confusion is understandable, because while i think oversight is an apt term in many ways, it does not cast much light. Trump fires intel ig, taps white house confidant for. Ten standards for oversight and transparency of national. For years now, jeff richelsons the us intelligence community has been the goto book for experts and laymen alike who want to know the latest about espionage organization and tradecraft in the united states.
And then on april 8only days after he had fired the intelligence community inspector. Reports preceded wholesale reforms of the intelligence community, including improving congressional oversight mechanisms. Obama administration has threatened to veto any intelligence bill that clarifies gaos authority to oversee the intelligence community, even. R street institute is a nonprofit, nonpartisan, public policy research organization.
It is designed for personnel from the various component organizations of the intelligence community, as well as individuals from any other national security or military department, agency or organization who have a need or interest in understanding congresss organization and internal processes and the institutions role in overseeing. The committees were created as a result of substantial exposure of intelligence community abuses after the watergate era. She argues that many of the biggest oversight problems. Strengthening congressional oversight of the intelligence. Parliamentary oversight of intelligence agencies openedition. Congress oversees the united states intelligence community, 19471994. Congressional oversight of the intelligence community. Strengthening congressional oversight of the intelligence community washington sept. Intelligence community oversight duties are distributed to both the executive and legislative branches. Congress and the president set the intelligence community ic free to make the world more secure. Department of energy office of intelligence and counterintelligence. The object of this thesis is to take a comprehensive look at the subject of. She argues that many of the biggest oversight problems lie with congressthe institution, not the parties or personalitiesshowing how.
920 233 52 223 335 687 63 1091 105 1638 1120 446 1048 786 719 160 1007 1557 1038 1303 1212 407 1094 801 1277 598 999 502 723 1027 1290